Security Issues

al_gorithm · 11-30-2005, 01:48 PM

Presumably, NT v5.x is or will be reporting our trading activity back to NT or someone. Would like to know exactly who will bereceiving what information and when, andwill trade info be transmitted generically (i.e.; collected without being associated with a specific NT user) or will our account info be transmitted back as well.

If you'll be addressing this issue in your early December notice, I can wait. Otherwise, please let us know when convenient.

Thank you.

al_gorithm

NinjaTrader_Ray · 11-30-2005, 03:31 PM

This depends on if your broker is collecting royalty payments or not. We will publish a list of supporting broker/fcms by year end. If your broker is collecting royalties then there is not activity being reported. If NT has to collect royalties then executions are reported to NT as they happen in real-time. Yes, execution is reported along with your license id. This information is used in the event that TT audits NinjaTrader. This information is required by TT for audit purposes. This information is submitted to an indpendant 3rd party auditor under NDA.

Ray

al_gorithm · 11-30-2005, 04:03 PM

NinjaTrader Wrote: This depends on if your broker is collecting royalty payments or not. We will publish a list of supporting broker/fcms by year end. If your broker is collecting royalties then there is not activity being reported. If NT has to collect royalties then executions are reported to NT as they happen in real-time. Yes, execution is reported along with your license id. This information is used in the event that TT audits NinjaTrader. This information is required by TT for audit purposes. This information is submitted to an indpendant 3rd party auditor under NDA.

Since our account numbers and login info, including passwords are held by NT, my main concern was whether or not any of this information would be transmitted along with an execution report. I can't imagine why that would be necessary, but I need to ask.

Ray, sometime before the forced switch to NT5, I think we should be told exactly what information will be transmitted (justX number ofcontracts traded or the specifics of a trade, e.g.; instrument, prices, long/short, etc.). It's certainly understandable why some information needs to be divulged, however, since the info really belongs to us, I think we have a right to know exactly what and specifically to whom it will be transmitted and be assured via a NDA that we have some security and recourse as well.

Thank you.

al_gorithm

P.S. From what I've seen you've done a marvelous job with NT5. Looking forward to making the switch.

11-30-2005, 01:48 PM	#1
al_gorithm Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: , , Posts: 22 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 times in 0 posts	imported post Presumably, NT v5.x is or will be reporting our trading activity back to NT or someone. Would like to know exactly who will bereceiving what information and when, andwill trade info be transmitted generically (i.e.; collected without being associated with a specific NT user) or will our account info be transmitted back as well. If you'll be addressing this issue in your early December notice, I can wait. Otherwise, please let us know when convenient. Thank you. al_gorithm
	Facebook Twitter YouTube

11-30-2005, 03:31 PM	#2
NinjaTrader_Ray Administrator Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Denver, CO, USA Posts: 11,164 Thanks: 6 Thanked 46 times in 32 posts	imported post This depends on if your broker is collecting royalty payments or not. We will publish a list of supporting broker/fcms by year end. If your broker is collecting royalties then there is not activity being reported. If NT has to collect royalties then executions are reported to NT as they happen in real-time. Yes, execution is reported along with your license id. This information is used in the event that TT audits NinjaTrader. This information is required by TT for audit purposes. This information is submitted to an indpendant 3rd party auditor under NDA. Ray Ray NinjaTrader Customer Service Use Kinetick, NinjaTrader’s preferred market data service - Learn More Free online training events - View Schedule
	Facebook Twitter YouTube

11-30-2005, 04:03 PM	#3
al_gorithm Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: , , Posts: 22 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 times in 0 posts	imported post NinjaTrader Wrote: This depends on if your broker is collecting royalty payments or not. We will publish a list of supporting broker/fcms by year end. If your broker is collecting royalties then there is not activity being reported. If NT has to collect royalties then executions are reported to NT as they happen in real-time. Yes, execution is reported along with your license id. This information is used in the event that TT audits NinjaTrader. This information is required by TT for audit purposes. This information is submitted to an indpendant 3rd party auditor under NDA. Since our account numbers and login info, including passwords are held by NT, my main concern was whether or not any of this information would be transmitted along with an execution report. I can't imagine why that would be necessary, but I need to ask. Ray, sometime before the forced switch to NT5, I think we should be told exactly what information will be transmitted (justX number ofcontracts traded or the specifics of a trade, e.g.; instrument, prices, long/short, etc.). It's certainly understandable why some information needs to be divulged, however, since the info really belongs to us, I think we have a right to know exactly what and specifically to whom it will be transmitted and be assured via a NDA that we have some security and recourse as well. Thank you. al_gorithm P.S. From what I've seen you've done a marvelous job with NT5. Looking forward to making the switch.
	Facebook Twitter YouTube

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode